| 1948 | Floyd Hunsberger, HB (AP-hm) |
| 1951 | Bob Heimerdinger, QB (AP-hm) |
| 1963 | George Bork, QB (AP-hm, UPI-hm) |
| 1965 | Ron Christian, QB (AP-hm) |
| 1969 | John LaLonde, FB (AP-hm) |
| 1971 | Willie Hatter, SE (AP-hm) |
| 1973 | Mark Kellar, FB (AP-hm, UPI-hm, FN-hm, K-hm) |
| 1977 | Frank Lewandoski, LB (AP-hm) |
| 1978 | Dave Petzke, SE (AP-3rd) |
| 1979 | Frank Lewandoski, LB (AP-hm) |
| | Randy Clark, OT (AP-hm) |
| | Steve Claussen, DE (AP-hm) |
| 1980 | Mike Terna, LB (AP-hm) |
| | Dave Petway, SS (AP-hm) |
| 1981 | Mike Chelovich, OG (AP-hm) |
| 1982 | Rich Barrent, OG (AP-hm) |
| | Max Gill, DT (AP-hm) |
| | Brian Glasgow, TE (AP-hm) |
| | Pete Roth, TB (AP-hm) |
| 1983 | Scott Bolzan, OT (AP-hm) |
| | Darryl Richardson, TB (AP-hm) |
| | Vince Scott, PK (AP-hm) |
| | Jeff Sanders, CB (AP-hm) |
| 1984 | Scott Kellar, DT (AP-hm) |
| | Todd Peat, OG (AP-hm) |
| | Todd Van Keppel, P (AP-hm) |
| 1985 | Doug Bartlett, NG (AP-hm) |
| | Todd Peat, OT (AP-hm) |
| 1986 | Todd Peat, OG (AP-3rd) |
| | Doug Bartlett, NG (AP-hm) |
| 1987 | Ted Karamanos, OG (AP-hm) |
| 1988 | Ron Delisi, ILB (AP-hm) |
| | Brett Tucker, CB (AP-hm) |
| 1989 | Ron Delisi, ILB (TSN-hm) |
| | Stacey Robinson, QB (TSN-hm, FN-hm) |
| 1990 | Stacey Robinson, QB (UPI-hm, FN-hm, PFW-hm) |
| | Cary Caliendo, DE (FN-hm) |
| | Adam Dach, FB (FN-hm) |
| | John Ivanic, PK (FN-hm) |
| | Eric Wenckowski, C (FN-hm) |
| 1991 | Adam Dach, FB (FN-hm) |
| | Steve Henriksen, ILB (FN-hm) |
| | Larry Wynn, FLK (FN-hm) |
| 1992 | LeShon Johnson, TB (UPI-hm, FN-hm) |
| | Brad Capes, OT (Football News-hm) |
| | Brian Steger, PK (FN-hm) |
| | Steve Wild, OLB (FN-hm) |
| 1993 | LeShon Johnson, TB (AP-1st, UPI-1st, FN-1st, K-1st, |
| | FN-1st, WC-1st, FWAA-1st, TSN-1st, PFW-1st) |
| | Gerald Nickelberry, LB (FN-hm) |
| | Tim O'Brien, OG (FN-hm) |
| | Raymond Roberts, TE (FN-hm) |
| | Brian Steger, PK (FN-hm) |
| 1994 | Chris O'Neal, C (FN-hm) |
| 2000 | Ryan Diem, OT (FN-3rd) |
| | Justin McCareins, FLK (FN-hm) |
| 2001 | Steve Azar, PK (FN-hm) |
| 2002 | Dan Sheldon, WR (FD-2nd, CFC-2nd; CNNSI-hm) |
| | Michael Turner, TB (FD-2nd, TSN-3rd, CNNSI-hm; PFW-hm) |
| 2003 | Steve Azar, PK (CFN-hm) |
| | Michael Turner, TB (AP-2nd; CNNSI-2nd; TSN-2nd; |
| | CSR-2nd; CFN-hm; R-hm) |
| 2004 | Dan Sheldon, PR (CFN-hm) |
| | Garrett Wolfe, TB (CFN-hm, CNNSI-hm) |
| 2005 | Sam Hurd, WR (SI-hm) |
| | Garrett Wolfe, TB (CFN-hm) |
| 2006 | Garrett Wolfe, TB (P-1st, AP-3rd, CFN-3rd; SI-hm) |
| | Doug Free, OT (CFN-3rd, PFW-hm) |
| 2007 | Larry English, DE (PS-4th) |
| 2008 | Larry English, DE (PS-3rd, PFW-hm) |
| 2011 | Scott Wedige, C (CBS-2nd) |
| | Chandler Harnish, QB (SI-hm) |
| | Trevor Olson, OT (PS, 4th) |
| 2012 | Jordan Lynch, All-Purpose (AP-2nd, PS-2nd); |
| | QB (CBS-3rd, SI-hm) |
| 2013 | Jordan Lynch, All-Purpose (AP-1st, PS-1st); |
| | QB (CBS-2nd, SI-hm) |
| | Jimmie Ward, S (SI-1st, AP-3rd, PS-4th) |
| | Tommylee Lewis, All-Purpose (SI-hm) |
| 1960 | Dick Metzcus, E (CoSIDA-2nd) |
| 1961 | Tom Beck, QB (CoSIDA-2nd) |
| 1962 | J. Walter Smith, DB (CoSIDA-hm) |
| 1973 | Jeff Eckmann, DT (CoSIDA-2nd) |
| 1976 | Jim Jacobson, OT (CoSIDA-2nd) |
| 1993 | Steve Wild, OLB (CoSIDA-2nd) |
| 1996 | Patrick Stephen, SS (CoSIDA-2nd) |
| 1997 | Patrick Stephen, FS (CoSIDA-2nd) |
| 1998 | Patrick Stephen, SS (CoSIDA-2nd) |
| 2000 | Thomas Hammock, TB (CoSIDA-1st) |
| 2001 | Thomas Hammock, TB (CoSlDA-1st) |
| 2003 | P.J. Fleck, WR (CoSIDA-2nd) |
| 2012 | Alan Baxter, DE (CoSIDA-1st) |
| | Nabal Jefferson, NG (CoSIDA-2nd) |
| | Jason Schepler, TE (CoSIDA-2nd) |
| 2002 | Jason Frank, DL (1st Team) |
| | Josh Haldi, QB (2nd Team |
| | Dan Sheldon, WR (2nd Team) |
| | Tim Vincent, OL (2nd Team) |
| 2003 | P.J. Fleck, WR (1st Team) |
| | Rob Lee, DB (1st Team) |
| | Jake VerStraete, OL (1st Team) |
| 2004 | Josh Haldi, QB (1st Team) |
| | Rob Lee, DB (1st Team) |
| | Dan Sheldon, WR (1st Team) |
| | Jake VerStraete, OL (1st Team) |
| 2006 | Brad Benson, DT (1st Team) |
| | Mark Reiter, SS (1st Team) |
| 2007 | Jon Brost, OT (1st Team) |
| 2008 | Jon Brost, OT (1st Team) |
| | Craig Rusch, DE (1st Team) |
| 2011 | Nabal Jefferson, DT |
| 2012 | Alan Baxter, DE |
| | Nabal Jefferson, NG |
| | Jason Schepler, TE |
| | Rob Sterling, FB |
| 1951 | Bob Heimerdinger, QB (AP-1st) |
| 1953 | Wes Luedeking, HB (WS-hm) |
| 1958 | Lew Flinn, QB (NAIA-2nd) |
| 1959 | Lew Flinn, QB (NAIA-2nd) |
| | Al Eck, E (NAIA-2nd) |
| | Joe Plaskas, FB (NAIA-hm) |
| 1960 | Al Eck, E (NAIA-2nd, AP-hm) |
| 1961 | Tom Beck, HB (NAIA-2nd) |
| 1962 | George Bork, QB (AP-1st, UPI-1st, WS-1st, NAIA-1st) |
| | Hugh Rohrschneider, E (AP-2nd, NAIA-2nd) |
| 1963 | George Bork, QB (AP-1st, UPI-1st, WS-1st, NAIA-1st) |
| | Hugh Rohrschneider, E (NAIA-2nd, AP-3rd) |
| | Bob Evans, C (NAIA-hm) |
| | Gary Stearns, E (NAIA-hm) |
| 1965 | Ron Christian, QB (AP-3rd) |
