| 1963 | George Bork, QB (voting unavailable) |
| 1990 | Stacey Robinson, QB (38th place, 2 pts, 2 3rd place votes) |
| 1993 | LeShon Johnson, TB (6th place, 176 pts, 5 1st place votes, 51 2nd place, 59 3rd place) |
| 2003 | Michael Turner, TB (18th place, 3 pts, 3 3rd place votes) |
| 2006 | Garrett Wolfe (11th place, 29 pts) |
| 2012 | Jordan Lynch (7th place, 52 pts) |
| 2013 | Jordan Lynch (3rd place, 558 pts) |
| 1977 | Allen Ross, TB (AP) vs. Ohio, Nov. 19 - Back |
| 1990 | Stacey Robinson, QB vs. Fresno State, Oct. 6 |
| | (ESPN, Football News, Sports Illustrated, Chicago Tribune) |
| 1993 | Scott Crabtree, QB vs. Nevada, Sept. 25 |
| | (Chicago Tribune, Sports Illustrated) |
| | LeShon Johnson, TB vs. Southern Illinois, Oct. 2(Chicago Tribune) |
| | LeShon Johnson, TB vs. Iowa, Nov. 6 (Chicago Tribune) |
| | Scott Crabtree, QB |
| 2003 | P.J. Fleck, WR vs. Ohio, Oct. 4 (USAToday.com) |
| 2004 | Garrett Wolfe, TB vs. Eastern Michigan, Nov. 20 |
| | (CollegeSportsReport.com) |
| 2006 | Garrett Wolfe, TB vs. Ball State, Sept. 30 |
| | (USA Today, Walter Camp, Sporting News) |
| 2007 | Larry English, DE vs. Idaho, Sept. 22 |
| | (Football Writers/Bronko Nagurski Award) |
| 2010 | Chad Spann, TB vs. Minnesota, Sept. 23 (Walter Camp Offensive) |
| 2012 | Jordan Lynch, QB vs. Army, Sept. 15 (Capital One Cup Impact Performer of the Week) |
| | Jordan Lynch, QB vs. Kent State, Nov. 30 (Capital One Cup |
| | Impact Performer of the Week) |
| 2013 | Jordan Lynch, QB vs. Central Michigan, Oct. 19 (Walter Camp Offensive) |
| | Jordan Lynch, QB vs. Purdue, Sept. 28 (AT&T All-America Player of the Week |
| | Jordan Lynch, QB vs. Eastern Michigan, Oct. 26 (AT&T All-America Player of the Week) |